How Civil Resistance Improves Inclusive Democracy

"How Civil Resistance Improves Inclusive Democracy" by Subindra Bogati (Nepal Peacebuilding Initiative), Titik Firawati (Northern Illinois University), Jonathan Pinckney (Horizons Project), and Ches Thurber (Northern Illinois University)

Abstract: Nonviolent civil resistance campaigns have a well-documented positive effect on democracy. Yet this relationship has been primarily based on measures of liberal or electoral democracy. The impact of civil resistance on egalitarian democracy, particularly the inclusion in state power and resources of historically excluded groups, has been less examined. This paper tests the hypotheses that initiating a political transition through civil resistance will advance gender, class, and ethnic inclusion relative to other transition modes. Using cross-national data on egalitarianism and exclusion from the Varieties of Democracy project, we find that civil resistance transitions (CRTs) produce gains in inclusion along all three of these dimensions greater than those observed in non-civil resistance transitions. Furthermore, we find that participation by marginalized groups in the civil resistance campaign leads to further advances in inclusion. Our findings indicate that civil resistance may be a powerful force for promoting the inclusion of the historically marginalized.

Discussants:

Reyko Huang (Texas A&M University)

Madhav Joshi (University of Notre Dame)

OPSC Coordinator:

Brad Smith (Vanderbilt University)